What were some arguments for conscription?
What were some arguments for conscription?
The return of conscription would revitalize the weakening civil-military link and remind people of their civil obligations. National service is an important way to instill common values and build character. Those who do not want to participate in military service are free to opt for an alternative national service.
Why is conscription controversial?
Conscription is controversial for a range of reasons, including conscientious objection to military engagements on religious or philosophical grounds; political objection, for example to service for a disliked government or unpopular war; sexism, in that historically only men have been subject to the draft; and …
Why should conscription be mandatory?
Mandatory national service would foster unity and bring people from diverse backgrounds together. Compulsory service would save the government money and provide benefits to all citizens. Performing national service would help young people mature and serve as a bridge to adulthood.
How did the conscription debate divide Australia?
The debate surrounding conscription divided the nation, especially in Queensland where the Labor Government of T J Ryan stood alone in opposing it. Campaigns leading up to the conscription referendum divided the community, as opposing groups presented their views in public meetings, marches and the press.
What are the pros and cons of conscription?
Top 10 Conscription Pros & Cons – Summary List
| Conscription Pros | Conscription Cons |
|---|---|
| Good preparation for the work world | May be an outdated concept |
| May be good for character development | Waste of time |
| You can earn some money | May interfere with your career |
| Conscription can promote patriotism | May go against ethical values |
Who was opposed to conscription and why?
A Momentous Debate. The 1917 conscription debate was one of the fiercest and most divisive in Canadian political history. French-Canadians, as well as many farmers, unionized workers, non-British immigrants, and other Canadians, generally opposed the measure.
Was conscription good or bad for Canada?
Conscription had an impact on Canada’s war effort. By the Armistice, 48,000 conscripts had been sent overseas, half of which served at the front, providing crucial soldiers for the Hundred Days campaign.
Was conscription a good idea?
Conscription is quite popular across the world and still plays an important role in many countries….Top 10 Conscription Pros & Cons – Summary List.
| Conscription Pros | Conscription Cons |
|---|---|
| Good to discipline young men | Accidents |
| Perseverance may increase | Confined freedom |
What were the effects of conscription?
The findings show that military service increases the likelihood of future crimes, mostly among males from disadvantaged backgrounds and with a previous criminal history. The only positive effect of conscription for this group is the decrease in disability benefits and the number of sick days.
What was the conscription debate and what impact did it have on Australia?
A government policy for conscription would have forced eligible Australian men into military service overseas with the AIF. Conscription was a contentious issue in the Australian community. It was hotly debated amongst Australia’s political and religious leaders at the time.
How did conscription affect Australia?
At the outbreak of the First World War, the number of people volunteering to enlist for the Australian Imperial Force (AIF) was so high that recruitment officers were forced to turn people away. As the war went on, casualty rates increased and the number of volunteers declined. By 1916 the AIF faced a shortage of men.
